To distract from Gaza
slaughter, Israel lobby manufactures antisemitism freakout
MAX
BLUMENTHAL·MAY 24, 2021
https://thegrayzone.com/2021/05/24/gaza-slaughter-israel-lobby-antisemitism/
With deceptively edited videos and dubious allegations, the Israel lobby
has manufactured an antisemitism epidemic to turn the media’s gaze away from
dead children in Gaza.
Following an 11-day assault on
the Gaza Strip in which the Israeli army killed over 220 people, including more
than 65 children, and days of videotaped rampages of
Jewish extremist mobs against Palestinian people and property inside Israeli
cities, Israel lobbyists in the US and Canada have launched a carefully
coordinated public relations campaign to deflect outrage.
Having failed to successfully defend massacres of entire families in
their homes and the deliberate demolition of
civilian residential towers and media offices in Gaza City, the US Israel lobby
and the Israeli government it advocates for have manufactured an epidemic of antisemitic
violence with the goal of portraying American Jewry as the true victim of the
crisis.
Led by the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), Israel
lobbyists have portrayed a series of street scuffles between supporters of
Palestine and pro-Israel activists as anti-Jewish pogroms. In nearly every
case, no evidence exists to substantiate claims that Jews were targeted as Jews for violent assault. There is
ample proof of deception, however, as video and photographic evidence reveals
pro-Israel elements provoking demonstrators, initiating violence and falsifying
or embellishing their testimonies.
Since the Israeli government and Palestinian political
factions signed a ceasefire, the media has provided Israel lobbyists with an
uncritical platform to baselessly accuse Palestine solidarity activists of
triggering a wave of antisemitic violence, and even claim without a shred of
evidence that Jews are being hunted in their homes.
Everyone from President
Joseph Biden to members of the progressive congressional
“Squad” have lent their voices to the chorus of condemnation. Meanwhile,
celebrity influencers have posted
blue squares on their Instagram accounts to symbolize
solidarity with an American Jewish community supposedly under siege.
The Israel Foreign Ministry has capitalized on the
moral panic with a tweet invoking the intersectional social justice lexicon of
woke millennials:
To all
of our Jewish brothers and sisters around the world, we see you, we hear you,
we stand with you.
In an apparent bid to burnish their reputations and
that of the movement they claim to represent, several prominent Palestine
solidarity activists and Muslim
online influencers have echoed the statements by elected
officials. Rather than challenge a narrative designed to denigrate Palestine
solidarity advocacy as bigoted and even criminal, these opportunistic elements
have inadvertently legitimized it.
Now, as the Israeli police round up hundreds of young
Palestinians citizens of Israel for participating in protests against their own
dispossession, the New York Police Department has begun doing the same,
arresting Palestinian American youth, jailing and investigating them for “hate
crimes” over their involvement in videotaped tussles with pro-Israel
demonstrators.
In many high-profile cases, however, video and
photographic evidence examined by The Grayzone contradicts the allegations made
by pro-Israel forces and reveals the stories of several accusers to be highly
deceptive, if not entirely false.
The case of the invisible yarmulke
A May 19 incident in midtown New York City has become
the centerpiece of the pro-Israel narrative of Palestinian pogroms targeting
Jews across America. According to the official story, a mob of Palestinian
youth hunted down and brutalized a lone Jewish man, Joseph Borgen, on his way
to a nearby pro-Israel rally.
In an interview with Borgen, CNN host Don Lemon
claimed he was “wearing a yarmulke,” or Jewish skullcap, when he was attacked.
Borgen repeated this claim in several subsequent media engagements.
“Before I can even react,” Borgen told Lemon, “I was
surrounded by a crowd of people who, as you saw in the video, proceeded to beat
me down and then, after the fact, pepper spray and mace me.”
New York Governor Andrew Cuomo quickly decried the
violence as an antisemitic hate crime, and insinuated that Borgen was wearing a
visible yarmulke. “I unequivocally condemn these brutal attacks on visibly
Jewish New Yorkers and we will not tolerate antisemitic violent gang harassment
and intimidation,” Cuomo declared.
Rep. Jamaal Bowman of New York, a member of the
progressive congressional “Squad,” also chimed in to portray the incident as an
example of “antisemitic
hate.”
The scuffle and its aftermath were captured on video
by a bystander, yet CNN played only a short portion showing several men
pummeling Borgen. The complete video and photographs taken immediately after
the melee reveal that Borgen was wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt – not a
yarmulke. Unless video surfaces showing he was visibly wearing a yarmulke,
Borgen appears to have misled the media to create the impression that he was
targeted for simply being Jewish in public.
Further, footage shows that Borgen had to be
restrained by three police officers as he attempted to charge at his accused
attackers while they ran off, challenging them to fight. “One on one!” he
barked repeatedly before lying back on the ground.
Moments after the incident, NYPD arrested a
23-year-old Palestinian man named Waseem Awawdeh and charged him with second
degree assault as a hate crime and attempted first degree gang assault.
Awawdeh, who was filmed striking Borgen with a crutch, was nursing an injury
and appears to have been the easiest person on the scene for police to capture.
A May
23 article in the right-wing, Murdoch-owned New York Post
attempted to portray Awawdeh as an unrepentant thug, quoting an anonymous
jailer claiming the accused had stated, “I would do it again.” Buried in the
article, however, was an account by several friends of the accuser who were
present: “Friends of Awawdeh’s who refused to give their names claimed Awawdeh
was attacked first. ‘They picked somebody that was weak, that was on
crutches,'” the Post reported.
The Grayzone received an identical account of
testimonies gathered from witnesses of the incident. They said that several
pro-Israel demonstrators attacked Awawdeh, who had a leg injury, triggering the
violent response captured on video.
NY1, a local New York City news outlet, reported that
“the clashes [in Midtown] started after several people threw water and juice
bottles out of a window at the pro-Palestinian demonstrators. That’s when the
two sides starting fighting each other.”
This version of events fits a pattern in which Israel
sympathizers provoke Palestinian demonstrators, and even initiate violence,
then mislead the media about the circumstances of the fighting to portray
themselves as blameless victims of antisemitic hate crimes.
“How many pro-Palestinian demonstrators did you wail away on?”
On May 19, a pair of Israeli citizens, Snir Dayan and
Amit Skornik, claimed a mob of Palestinian American demonstrators assaulted
them in midtown New York City in what they described as an antisemitic attack.
According to an article in Fox
News which painted the incident as a hate crime, “Dayan said he
recalled seeing ‘a bunch of pro-Palestinian protests outside’ and decided to
attach a small Israeli flag he had in his apartment to his motorcycle as a
‘quiet’ form of protest.” The Israeli claimed to Fox that a mob of 30 Palestinian
protesters spontaneously attacked him and his friend after they heard him
speaking Hebrew.
However, video of the incident shows Dayan throwing
the first punch with an Israeli flag wrapped around his fist. It is unclear if
any blows were exchanged before the recording began. After NYPD officers
intervened to separate the dueling groups, they cuffed Dayan and escorted him
to a police wagon as he taunted the demonstrators with Israeli nationalist
chants. He was then arrested, ostensibly because he appeared to have initiated
the violence.
It turned out that both Dayan and Skornik were Israeli
soldiers who had served in the Golani Brigades, a special forces division that
participated in Israel’s 2014 assault on the Gaza Strip during which Israeli
forces killed 551 children.
What’s more, Skornik attempted to milk the street
fight to raise money for his fellow Golani Brigade soldiers. On his Facebook
page, he complained that
GoFundMe refused to authorize the fundraiser, which was advertised with images
of himself and Dayan proudly punching pro-Palestinian protesters.
Both Dayan and Skornik seem well-trained in mixed
martial arts and other forms of close quarters combat. In fact, Skornik is part
of a family
dynasty of Israeli martial arts experts. His father, Guy
Skornik, operates a company called Skornik Israeli Combat,
while Dayan has posted
video of himself sparring in martial arts.
Back home in Israel, Hebrew media turned the two
self-proclaimed victims into heroic warriors, openly lionizing
them for trading punches with pro-Palestine protesters on the
streets of New York.
“How many pro-Palestinian demonstrators did you wail
away on? That’s the question that interests me the most,” Israeli Channel 13’s
far-right host, Avri Gilad, asked the two former soldiers.
“At the end end of the video,” Dayan said, “you can
see that they tried to outflank us on the other side of the sidewalk. I ran
towards them, I hit one of them, and two, three, four seconds later I was in
handcuffs, with two to three police officers accompanying me to the cruiser.”
“You are first of all a source of pride!” the host,
Gilad, told Dayan and Skornik. “You are exactly the Jews and Israelis we want
there, and not all those bleeding hearts, the [Jewish] Americans that are being
betrayed…”
A Facebook post promoting Skornik and Dayan’s
appearance on Israel’s Channel 13 was deluged with supportive anti-Arab
commentary.
Canadian politicians condemn assaults by violent Zionist hate group… as
antisemitic hate crimes
The pattern of deceptively edited video appearing to
show Palestine solidarity activists attacking supporters of Israel and
triggering angry denunciations of antisemitic violence from top politicians has
also surfaced in Canada.
On May 15, video surfaced from a Palestine Youth
Movement protest in Toronto that seemed to show young Canadian Arabs beating a
gray-haired pro-Israel man with a wooden stick. Doug Ford, the premier of
Ottawa, and Toronto Mayor John Tory followed the Canadian Israel lobby’s lead
in immediately
denouncing the scene as an antisemitic hate crime.
“Hate, antisemitism and violence have no place in our
city,” Tory said in response to the video. “Any violence against our city’s
Jewish community or members of any other community in Toronto is absolutely
unacceptable.”
However, more complete video of the scuffle revealed
that pro-Israel forces initiated the violence against Palestine solidarity demonstrators
who were attempting to retreat. Further, several of those among the pro-Israel
mob were members of the Jewish Defense League, a violent extremist organization
responsible for numerous brutal assaults and assassinations of Palestinian
Americans, and were armed at the time with knives and baseball bats.
In a separate incident in Toronto, peaceful
pro-Palestinian counter-demonstrators outside a rally organized by a who’s who
of Canadian Israel lobby groups came under attack from Jewish Defense League
thugs threatening to run them over with vehicles and maim them with weapons.
Toronto police officers could be seen in video of the incident reaching for
their service pistols in fear as they sought to hold back the mob of Zionist
hooligans.
After video surfaced showing that Tory and Ford had
wrongly denounced pro-Palestine forces and falsely accused them of antisemitic
violence, the Canadian Broadcast Corporation (CBC) asked the
lawmakers if they planned to retract their statements.
Tory refused to back away from his erroneous comments,
while a spokesperson for Ford declared, “The Premier’s statement stands.”
Dishonestly framed video clips feed the media outrage
The deceptively edited and dishonestly framed video
clips that underpin the Israel lobby’s antisemitism narrative are almost too
numerous to track. However, two viral videos that purport to show anti-Jewish
violence deserve closer scrutiny.
Breitbart, the far-right, xenophobic website conceived
by the late Andrew Breitbart following a
meeting in Jerusalem with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu, published a video headlined as
follows: “At a pro-Palestinian rally in Washington, DC, Tuesday, several
marches shoved and assaulted a counter-protester.”
Though the video shows pro-Palestinian demonstrators
shoving a man, he was not a pro-Israel “counter-protester.” Ramsey Aburdene, a
Palestinian American raised in Washington DC, said he had been falsely accused
by a fellow protester of vandalizing the street near the Israeli embassy in
Northwest DC, and was momentarily pushed around by demonstrators who mistakenly
believed the allegation.
“This was in no way an antisemitic attack,” Aburdene
told The Grayzone. “It was just a dumb situation that quickly got out of
control because one individual was determined to escalate the situation.
Everyone involved was apologetic to me and very embarrassed by the situation.”
Footage of another incident in West Los Angeles has
elicited outrage and condemnations from politicians including LA Mayor Eric
Garcetti, who slammed what he called “an
organized antisemitic attack.” According to media coverage of the incident, a
caravan of pro-Palestinian motorists parading down La Cienega Boulevard began
attacking Jewish diners. “It was a hate crime. It was prepared, they came to
fight with Jewish people,” a non-Jewish diner claimed
to CBS.
Though a fight ensued between diners and members of
the pro-Palestine caravan, it remains unclear if anyone at the restaurant was
targeted based on their religion or ethnicity. In fact, the only person who
sought medical treatment after the scuffle was the non-Jewish man.
Further, video posted on social media by Sia
Kordestani, a staffer at the American Jewish Committee – a major Israel lobby
organization – shows a diner shouting, “Fuck you!” at the caravan and throwing
what appears to be glasses and cutlery at people in the cars. “Some threw
things back” at the caravan, Kordestani wrote.
To be sure, footage of the ensuing fight was ugly, and
some of those involved may have committed crimes. But like other high-profile
videotaped incidents, the violence appears to have been motivated by an angry
political dispute over Israel-Palestine, not ethno-religious animus. Indeed,
despite claims by witnesses, there is little to no evidence to demonstrate that
anyone at the sushi restaurant was targeted simply for being Jewish. Los
Angeles police are nonetheless investigating the incident as a potential hate
crime.
The ADL exaggerates antisemitism with bogus data and anti-Palestinian
propaganda
At the forefront of the narrative alleging a
nationwide crisis in antisemitic violence is the Anti-Defamation League, or
ADL. The heavily-funded outfit is at once a public relations juggernaut that
partners with Silicon Valley
tech barons, corporate media and celebrity
influencers; an Israel lobbying powerhouse that takes US law
enforcement officers to Israel on propaganda junkets; and a
private intelligence agency that spied on activists opposed to South
African apartheid during the 1980’s, and which does the same to
those battling apartheid today in Israel-Palestine.
ADL CEO and former bottled
water salesman Jonathan Greenblatt has been a virtual fixture
on CNN and other networks since the antisemitism outrage erupted. During
a May 20 interview
with CNN, Greenblatt claimed, “There was one report of cars driving
through Jewish neighborhoods in Los Angeles throwing bottles at homes that had
the Jewish mezzuzah on the doors.” He provided no evidence for the incendiary
claim, and his host asked for none.
The ADL has also peddling a dubiously sourced report
headlined, “Uptick in
Antisemitic Incidents Linked to Recent Mideast Violence.” Claiming a
whopping 193 “antisemitic incidents” in the mere span of a week, the ADL report
classified “dozens of anti-Israel rallies” and chants of “Intifada” as acts of
anti-Jewish bigotry.
In his 2009 documentary on the weaponization of
antisemitism, Defamation,
Israeli filmmaker Yoav Shamir exposed the farcical methodology the ADL has used
to document supposedly antisemitic incidents. As ADL senior staff revealed on
camera to Shamir, the organization enters virtually any complaint it receives
into its database, including anonymous claims of anti-Israel media coverage and
workplace disputes. It then cites the data to generate the specter of rising
public hostility toward Jews – and fundraise off its constituents’ fears.
When Shamir asked the ADL for help following up on an
antisemitic attack, its staff was unable to provide him with a single incident
to cover.
Despite the ADL’s well-established record of
hucksterism and its propagandistic conflation of Palestine solidarity activism
with antisemitism, its recent report received promotional boosts from the National Basketball Association and Sacha Baron-Cohen, the British Jewish comedian best known for
portraying Central Asians and Arabs as stereotypically barbaric and primitive antisemites.
(Baron-Cohen was successfully sued in 2009 by a Palestinian Christian peace
activist whom he falsely portrayed in his film, Bruno, as a terrorist in league
with Osama Bin Laden.)
The Corbyn-ing of Palestine solidarity in the US
The US Israel lobby’s cynical manufacturing of a wave
of antisemitism in the wake of rising Palestine solidarity activity closely
resembles the campaign waged by its political counterparts across the Atlantic
to remove Jeremy Corbyn as leader of the UK’s Labour Party. Though Corbyn was a
veteran anti-racist campaigner – or perhaps because he was –
the British Israel
lobby and the Israeli embassy
in London staged a coordinated effort to brand him and his
progressive supporters in Labour as vicious Jew haters.
In most cases, the lobby’s accusations were based
on wild distortions and outright lies,
however, Corbyn and his allies routinely opted against pushing back, and
even withdrew his
own complaint that antisemitism inside Labour had been cynically exaggerated.
In the end, supporters of Palestinian rights were purged from
Labour in droves and Corbyn was replaced with Sir Keir Starmer, a grim centrist
with strong Zionist
sympathies, deep national
security state ties, and the charisma of a filing cabinet.
“The beast is slain,” a prominent UK Israel
lobbyist declared,
boasting that Corbyn had been “slaughtered” thanks to “our spies and intel.”
The Israel lobby’s latest blitz of antisemitism
allegations has successfully deflected US media’s attention away from Israel’s
deliberate bombing of civilian towers and extermination of entire families in
Gaza, the pogroms Jewish extremists waged against Palestinians just minutes
from Tel Aviv, and the ongoing police round-up of Palestinian citizens of
Israel. In turn, it has cast an American Jewish community basking in almost
unimaginable affluence and privilege as the true victims of the Israel-Palestine
crisis, while impugning a movement agitating for the rights of a dispossessed
and colonized people as bigoted criminals.
We are all Jeremy Corbyn now.
MAX BLUMENTHAL
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
The
editor-in-chief of The Grayzone, Max Blumenthal is an award-winning journalist
and the author of several books, including best-selling Republican Gomorrah, Goliath, The Fifty One Day War, and The Management of
Savagery. He has
produced print articles for an array of publications, many video reports, and
several documentaries, including Killing Gaza. Blumenthal founded The Grayzone in 2015 to shine
a journalistic light on America's state of perpetual war and its dangerous
domestic repercussions.
