El-Sayed coverage shows how the media is out of step with the public on Israel
Abdul El-Sayed's victory over GOP candidate Mike
Rogers laid waste to the media narrative that El-Sayed "divided"
Democrats over Israel. Yet this obvious Islamophobic bias still dominates
coverage of the first Muslim U.S. Senator.
By Michael Arria November 16, 2026
Democrat Abdul El-Sayed’s victory over GOP candidate
Mike Rogers laid waste to a dubious media narrative that dominated the Michigan
Senate race.
The story was that El-Sayed’s candidacy had “divided”
the Democratic Party because he’s a critic of the U.S./Israel military
relationship.
In the weeks leading up to the election, the
mainstream press ran multiple pieces on the topic, nearly all following a
similar formula. A couple of local pro-Israel Democrats were quoted; the public
trepidation of a pro-Israel local lawmaker was cited; El-Sayed’s connection to
left-wing Twitch streamer Hasan Piker was referenced; and declarations of
disarray were made.
“Democrats are still struggling to unite behind
El-Sayed after the primary exposed deep disagreements over Israel,” claimed one PBS article.
A cursory look at the data quickly reveals that,
insofar as such disagreements exist, they certainly aren’t deep, as El-Sayed’s
position on Israel is consistent with the vast majority of Democratic voters.
A March 2026 Pew Research Center poll found that 80 percent of
Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents have a negative view of Israel,
up from 69 percent in 2025 and 53 percent in 2022. Days before the
election, a Marist poll found that despite claims of a split party, 95% of
Michigan Democrats planned to vote for El-Sayed.
In the end, only 4% of Democrats voted for Rogers. 5% of Michigan
Republicans actually voted for El-Sayed, but you’d be hard-pressed to find a
single article imagining that the Republican Party was “divided” in Michigan.
The phony narrative around El-Sayed may have died, but
the assumptions that fueled it remain. As a Muslim of Arab descent, his
criticisms of Israel are viewed as more suspicious than those of the average
progressive, with a frequent implication in the media that they may point to
deep-rooted antisemitism.
In an appearance on MS Now, the morning after
the election, Morning Joe co-anchor Willie Geist asked El-Sayed what he would do to protect Jewish voters
who might be uneasy about his views.
“I’m committed to Jewish safety, and we are united
against discrimination,” explained El-Sayed in his response. “The U.S. spends
billions to carry out genocide and apartheid against Palestinians. The genocide
in Gaza with our complicity is continuing right now. Nobody wants to talk about
that.”
El-Sayed’s answer went viral, and he was commended
across social media for it, but the original question was curious, given that
he had consistently said as much on the campaign trail.
The Geist question also came after the anchor had
pressed El-Sayed on why he supports cutting off military aid to Israel, thus
equating continued support for the country with the issue of Jewish safety.
El-Sayed faced a similar line of questioning on The
View, where co-host Sara Haines took him to task for comments he made about
the March 2026 attack on a Michigan synagogue.
El-Sayed had immediately condemned the attack, while
pointing out that multiple members of the assailant’s family had been killed in
an Israeli airstrike on Lebanon. “Hurt people hurt people,” said the
Senator-elect.
In response to backlash over the comment, El-Sayed
apologized, but this wasn’t enough for Haines, who somehow connected the
remarks to his religion.
“Do you think that leaders have a responsibility to
challenge the extremist views in their own religion, especially considering
you’re the first Muslim senator of the United States?” she asked.
After Democrat James Talarico was declared the winner
of the Texas Senate race, CNN asked him whether he would “stand up” to members of his
party like El-Sayed.
Why is El-Sayed, who just prevailed in a swing state
running on a program of affordability and health care access, being grilled on
Jewish safety, called out over the actions of “extremist” Muslims, and
allegedly posing such a threat to the country that fellow members of his party
must stand up to him?
The media’s pro-Israel bias is undoubtedly a factor
here, but it’s also important to remember that El-Sayed’s primary win over
Haley Stevens triggered a wave of Islamophobia across social media. One Washington Post study
found that almost 1 in 3 posts about El-Sayed from right-wing figures mentioned
Islam, Muslims, or Sharia Law within two weeks of his August victory.
In a recent Zeteo piece, reporter Prem Thakker
points out that these two media threads are very much connected and that
El-Sayed is being held to a different set of rules than his colleagues.
“We are seeing a type of double, perhaps even triple,
standard that is genuinely devoid of any logic or sensibility, other than the
media’s final attempts to harden the conflation of Israel with Jewish people,
and discipline the ascendant left by any means necessary,” Thakker writes.
Back in reality, a supermajority of Jewish Americans now believe that AIPAC and Israel
are increasing antisemitism in the United States. When Hasan Piker made the
same claim, he was denounced by many as a dangerous antisemite whom El-Sayed
needed to denounce in order to have any chance of winning.
That analysis turned out to be wildly off, but such
setbacks haven’t shifted the mainstream media’s coverage of the first Muslim
U.S. Senator.
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario