What happens to the Middle East if Russia and the US stop being enemies?
The US might ignore Russia reasserting itself in Libya
and Syria, but Trump and Putin will still compete over Gulf cash
By Sean Mathews
Published date: 7
March 2025
https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/what-happens-middle-east-if-russia-and-us-stop-being-enemies
Some call it the end of the post-war order. Others, a
grand realignment. Regardless of how it's defined, the Middle East faces a new
paradigm: what happens when the US stops viewing Russia as a foe and instead as
a potential partner, or at the very least, a neutral actor?
American diplomats and analysts are still struggling
to come to grips with this potentially historic shift.
When asked about a report that Israel was lobbying the
Trump administration to let Russia keep its military bases in Syria, one career
US diplomat in the region replied, “Well, that would be against our national
interests?”
They responded with silence when asked what would
happen if the US president didn’t see it that way.
Trump has said he wants to partner with Russia for
“incredible opportunities”.
On Friday, Trump doubled down, saying he found it
easier to deal with Russia than Ukraine, a country the US had been supplying
arms and intelligence to until recently. Asked about Russia’s widespread
attacks on Ukraine’s energy grid, Trump said Putin was "doing what anybody
else would do”.
Trump, Nixon and the China analogy
The US view of Russia as a foe working against its
interests has defined the Middle East since the end of WWII, when Franklin
Delano Roosevelt courted Saudi Arabia for Gulf oil. In the following decades,
the US worked to counter the Soviet Union across the region.
The US’s support for Israel in the 1973 War led to an
eventual peace treaty between Israel and Egypt. In the process, Egyptian
President Anwar Sadat evicted Soviet military advisors who had been welcomed by
Gamal Abdel Nasser.
Until December 2024, the United States viewed the
toppled Syrian Assad dynasty as a vehicle for nefarious Russian power
projection.
Trump’s allies looking to explain his outreach to
Putin have said he is trying to break up a bloc of states, mainly Russia, Iran
and China, from coordinating against the US. They add that Trump’s overtures
echo the strategic diplomacy of Richard Nixon and Henry Kissinger opening up to
China in the 1970s.
Chas Freeman, a former US diplomat, whose
career spanned almost three decades, told Middle East Eye it was a “false
comparison”.
“A better analogy to Trump’s opening to Putin is Sadat
going to Jerusalem.”
Freeman is reliable on the subject considering he was
the interpreter for Nixon’s trip.
In the Middle East, Trump’s bid to work with Putin may
reflect his priorities and a geopolitical world view. Some of Trump’s
confidants have raised the alarm about Turkey’s expanding influence.
Steve Bannon and Mike Flynn's world view
Steve Bannon, a former Trump advisor whose podcast War
Room has become required listening to those seeking to discern Trump’s world
view, said recently that Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan was “one of the
most dangerous leaders” in the world and wants to "re-establish the
Ottoman Empire”.
Trump himself said that the collapse of the Assad
government in Syria was merely an “unfriendly takeover” by Turkey. Trump wants
to withdraw US troops from northeastern Syria. According to Reuters, Israel has
told the Trump administration one way to reduce Turkey’s influence in the
country would be via Russia.
“Donald Trump wants to be out of Syria. I can imagine
that Russia and Israel cooperate to limit Turkish influence there and Trump
just says, ‘I don’t care. You guys deal with Turkey',” Robert Ford, the US’s
former ambassador to Syria, told MEE.
Trump has selected traditional Republicans who have
been hostile to Russia, like Secretary of State Marco Rubio and national
security advisor Mike Waltz. But career US diplomats and defence officials say
their influence is limited.
For example, Rubio sat silent as Vice President JD
Vance challenged Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky at the White House last
month. Steve Witkoff, Trump’s unconfirmed Middle East envoy, was the one tapped
to meet Putin - speaking for roughly three hours -in Russia.
The gatekeepers to Trump’s selection of appointees are
not diehard Russia hawks but those who believe the US should engage Moscow.
Officials looking to get into the White House have
courted Mike Flynn, Trump’s former national security advisor who was ousted
from his first administration over his discussions with the Russians.
Trump said he offered Flynn "about ten jobs" in his new
administration.
Can Russia broker a US-Iran deal?
Trump hasn’t revived ties with Russia for the Middle
East - he wants a ceasefire in Ukraine - but there are areas in the region
where Russia is trying to entice the White House.
On Wednesday, the Kremlin said that future talks
between Russia and the US would include discussions on Iran's nuclear
programme. Spokesman Dmitry Peskov appeared to acknowledge a report that Russia
offered to mediate between the Islamic Republic and the Trump administration.
Trump says he wants a diplomatic deal with Iran over
its nuclear programme. On Friday, he said he sent a letter to Iran’s Supreme
Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, asking for talks.
The Obama administration, which tried its own
so-called reset with Russia, leaned on the Kremlin during the 2015 nuclear
talks.
“Obama gave Russia a lot of concessions for its
mediation in the 2015 nuclear deal,” Anna Borshchevskaya, a Russia expert at
the Washington Institute For Near East Policy, told MEE.
“In practice, Russia acted as Iran’s lawyer, watering
down US concerns about Iranian nuclear proliferation.”
In fact, Russia played a key role for the US after the
deal was signed, with Iran shipping excess uranium to Russia to ensure it
couldn’t be used as a bomb.
In return, Russia, which shares the Caspian Sea with
Iran, reaped economic benefits, sealing a deal to construct a
nuclear power plant.
Ford, however, cautioned that Russia’s utility to the
US on nuclear talks might be limited. The Obama administration itself bypassed
Russia and its European powers to negotiate directly with Iran during the
talks.
“Kerry was meeting Zarif directly and then
back-briefing the Europeans. I can’t imagine the US or Iranians would rely on
the Russians. This is such a life and death matter for Tehran,” Ford said,
referring to former Secretary of State John Kerry and Foreign Minister Mohammad
Zarif, who negotiated the 2015 deal.
Freeman said he is skeptical a grand Russian-US
rapprochement will materialise.
"Things are rearranging themselves in very
unpredictable ways. It's like a kaleidoscope. You bang two sides together, and
no one knows what new pattern will be formed,” but he said that in the Middle
East, what's likely is not “active cooperation, but American silence”.
Chasing Gulf money
If the war in Ukraine ends and Trump lifts sanctions
on Russia, he could dent some of the Gulf states' economic activity.
The United Arab Emirates and Russia were deepening
ties before the Biden administration slapped sanctions on Russia. But after
that, the UAE became a hub for re-exporting sanctioned goods.
Russia could stop paying Emirati middlemen and buy
directly from the United States if Trump ends the sanctions.
Borshchevskaya said that Russia could also look to
make up lost ground in its weapons sales to the Gulf states if Trump lifts
sanctions.
Even during the war, the Arab Gulf talked to Russia
about arms sales. Russian arms manufacturers displayed their goods alongside
the US at the UAE’s arms expos in recent years.
US officials who spoke with MEE said they believe the
US’s advantage over Russia in the oil-rich Gulf makes it a tough competition.
Countries like Qatar, the UAE, and Saudi Arabia are deeply wired into US air
defence systems, such as the Patriots and THAADS.
Meanwhile, the UAE is deepening its cooperation with
the US in high-tech sectors like AI, where Russia struggles to compete.
Even as Trump riles Europe, he is courting the Gulf
region. On Friday he announced that Saudi Arabia would be his first trip abroad
as president after Riyadh agreed to invest $1 trillion in American companies
over a four-year period.
“They’ve agreed to do that, so I’m going to be going
there… probably over the next month and a half.”