As Israel's image collapses, US billionaires move to silence dissent
17 November 2025
Facing record opposition to Israel's genocide in Gaza,
America's elites are seizing control of news and tech companies to suppress
criticism and rescue a crumbling narrative
https://www.middleeasteye.net/opinion/israels-image-collapses-us-billionaires-move-silence-dissent
Public support for Israel in the United States has reached historic lows.
A Gallup poll in July found that 32 percent of Americans
approve of the Israeli campaign in Gaza, while 60 percent disapprove, a 10 percent drop in
support from the previous September.
Pew Research Center findings showed that a third of American adults (33
percent) say the country sends Israel too much military aid, a larger portion
of the population than those who say the US provides the right amount (23
percent) or not enough (8 percent).
A majority of Americans hold a negative view of Israel and
report being "extremely" or "very" concerned about its
military strikes killing Palestinian civilians and about starvation among Palestinians in Gaza.
A New York Times/Siena poll revealed that there are slightly more Americans
who sympathise with the Palestinians than those who sympathise with Israel.
Israel's popularity crisis is particularly acute among
young Americans, with only nine percent of those aged 18 to 34 backing Israel's military action in the Strip.
Forty-two percent of those in the 18 to 29
cohort say the US
grants Israel too much military aid, compared to 21 percent whose opinion is
that the US is giving the right amount or too little.
One influential ghoul after another - from Hillary Clinton to wealthy tech
investors and members
of Congress - has attributed this shift to TikTok, as if American youth are
incapable of independently concluding that it is wrong to repeatedly set fire to
tents filled with
displaced persons.
Amid the decline in pro-Israel sentiment, which
is functionally
the same as a decline
in support for US imperialism in and beyond the Middle East, the US ruling
class is aggressively asserting control over powerful media organs.
Control of the narrative
On 25 September, US President Donald Trump issued an executive
order mandating
that for TikTok to continue operating in the US, one or more Americans had to
own the majority of the platform.
Trump's actions, it is worth noting, build on the
Biden administration's approach to
TikTok, which also
called for US control of the app, a position with bipartisan support in
Congress.
Accordingly, a group of US investors led by the software firm
Oracle is taking
control of 65 percent of TikTok.
Oracle is set to oversee TikTok's US operations,
provide cloud services for user data storage and secure a licence to take
charge of the app's algorithm.
Oracle founder Larry Ellison is one of the top donors to the Friends of the
Israel Defense Forces (FIDF), a US nonprofit that effectively subsidises the
Israeli military. He has said that he feels a "deep emotional connection
to the State of Israel" and "we", seemingly a reference to
Oracle, will "do everything we can to support the country of
Israel".
A similar process has unfolded in traditional news
media. In August, the Ellison family's media company, Skydance - an outfit
financially supported by Larry Ellison and run by his son, David - acquired
Paramount, a movie studio that owns CBS and a host of cable channels.
Bari Weiss, a talentless
behind-kisser and
tattle-tale passionately opposed to free speech and to Palestinian freedom, has
been named CBS News's editor-in-chief.
Now, the Ellison family has its sights set on Warner
Bros Discovery, which owns HBO, TBS and CNN.
Media capture
While there is ample space for pro-Palestine messaging
on TikTok, it is not as if traditional news outlets like CBS have a record of
supporting Palestinian liberation.
CBS, like all major corporate media in the United States, far more often than not
produces content favourable to US-Israeli objectives in West Asia.
For example, in the last year, the CBS News website
ran 2,575 stories that mention Gaza, with only 388 containing the word
"genocide".
In other words, in a period that mostly predates the
Ellison-Weiss regime, only 15 percent of the site's Gaza coverage mentioned the
crime of crimes, even as one credible source after another has concluded that Israel has carried out a genocide in the
Strip.
Thus, CBS News already had a record of what I have
previously called genocide
denial by omission, a
form of media distortion that helps enable genocide by reducing the likelihood
that enough of the American population will accurately understand that their
government is party to an extermination
campaign to bring it
to a halt.
CNN, for its part, helped manufacture consent for the
Gaza genocide by making pro-Israel
propaganda its
official policy.
What the latest developments in the media landscape
represent are, as with so much else in the Trump era, a movement towards
vulgar, unabashed assertions of raw power that dispense with the typically
hollow and hypocritical pretences of an open and democratic society that
characterised America's recent past.
Losing legitimacy
The American state and the billionaires it serves know
that they cannot win the Palestine-Israel debate, and they see that their
colonial outpost is rapidly losing perceived legitimacy.
Trying to stamp out content that makes Israel and the
US look bad by occasionally giving audiences a partial glimpse of US-Zionist
barbarism in Palestine is a sign of desperation rather than strength.
The gambit will not work.
Media outlets do not operate in a vacuum, and people
are not empty vessels that news firms can simply fill with whatever they like.
Israel's image cannot be restored, and neither can
that of the US ruling class, certainly not among young people who won't soon
forget their peers being suspended,
expelled or chewed up
by the US's merciless deportation
machine.
They won't soon forget their colleges turning riot cops against them or putting snipers on the
roofs of school
buildings during pro-Palestine student protests. They won't soon forget the mainstream media lying to
them while Palestinian journalists showed them the grieving parents whose
bereavement was enabled by western, and especially American, taxpayers.
If the Gaza "ceasefire" holds, the international movement in solidarity
with Palestine may lose some of its energy in the West.
However, even if the frequency of mass demonstrations
in western cities dwindles, the organisations and alliances formed after 7
October are not all going to disappear.
Indeed, many of these formations predate 2023, with
the Boycott,
Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS)
movement having established nodes around the world and achieved numerous
successes since its inception in 2005.
That institutional memory cannot be erased by media
manipulation, nor can the experience, political organising skills and
self-confidence that pro-Palestine activists have gained by fighting, and
sometimes winning, through 20 years of BDS or two years of resisting genocide.